Brother's Pizza & Restaurant Cortland
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant Logo

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

4.6893 reviews

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant stands at 144 S High St, in Cortland. This local gem brings a taste of Italy to Ohio. Known for its cozy vibe, it offers a variety of pizzas and subs. Here, flavors meet tradition. Fresh ingredients create dishes that locals love.

The menu highlights classic Italian fare. It's a place to grab a quick lunch or spend an evening with friends. Patrons enjoy homemade bread, delicious pizzas, and rich subs. With a commitment to quality, each bite tells a story of culinary passion.

Unique touches, like daily fresh bread, make Brother's special. The ambiance reflects a casual Italian eatery, perfect for everyone. Whether dining in, taking out, or enjoying home delivery, the experience remains delightful. Brother's captures the essence of community through food.

About

Cortland, Ohio, is home to Brother's Pizza & Restaurant, a beloved local establishment. Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, it exudes warmth and friendliness. Customers range from families to solo diners, all drawn by its inviting atmosphere.

Opened years ago, the restaurant has become a staple in the community. Regulars appreciate the attention to detail and consistent quality. Each dish reflects the dedication of the team, who take pride in serving authentic Italian cuisine.

Brother's roots in the community run deep. The owners share a commitment to customer satisfaction. Their relationship with locals fosters trust and loyalty. Visitors often feel like part of the family, enjoying the comforting flavors of home-cooked meals.

Get in Touch

144 S High St, Cortland, OH 44410, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-21:00
  • Tuesday 11:00-21:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-21:00
  • Thursday 11:00-21:00
  • Friday 11:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-21:00
  • Sunday 16:00-21:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Excellent Pizza and Stromboli's. They have other Italian entres as well but haven't tried them yet. The bread/crust is delicious! Perfectly cooked and flavorful. The ambiance here is also special. Feels like little Italy in NYC! Check it out"

- David B.

"Friday around 4pm. Not crowded but steady flow of customers for take out and delivery. Large menu of pizza, pasta, subs and such. Ordered a half white/half regular. Thin crust was ready in about 10 min. No table service; place your order, serve and bus yourself. Regular pizza was good. A bit salty for my taste. White was very spicey; peppers chopped very fine. Heavy on the garlic. Overall average pizza. Kudos for friendly prompt service. UPDATE Nov 22, Meatball and Eggplant Parm subs for lunch. Outstanding. UPDATE: May 2024: A busy Sunday so we stopped on the way home to order and pickup dinner. A steady flow of people, mostly picking up phone orders. 6-7 people behind the counter. We ordered egg plant parm and manicotti were told it would be 30 min. 55 min later we are told the order was ready. Lots of apologies for the delay. We got it home to find the manicotti cold and undercooked. Once cooked we ate a late supper and wondered what happened. The pizza builder was busy the whole time. The girl making all other meals just couldn't give a good idea when food would be ready and couldn't understand why promising 30 min and delivering at 55 would be a problem. Brothers gave themselves a black eye and lost some stars tonight."

- Gary C.

"Amazing Italian and meatball subs at this place. Fresh bread and ingredients with so much taste! Skip the chains and go to this place for an amazing sandwich. Bring cash as they don't take debit cards. Try one of these subs, today!"

- Ken B.

"Old school place that makes bread fresh daily for their awesome subs. Pizza is excellent, and chicken parm slaps! Best staff and owners! Cortland loves you"

- Justin W.

"Taste from my past! I grew up in Cortland, and moved away 35 years ago. When it comes to Submarine sandwiches I try to make it here a few times throughout the year because I love their homemade sub bread and the service is quick and pleasant. It's a great combination of delicious and nostalgic."

- Holly S.

"I was just at this wonderful Pizza restaurant because I was out in Cortland. I lucked out. THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. Please take your time and go Ps we ate most of it in the car. It was too good to wait."

- Kelly M.

"NY style delicious and stromboli also. Side sauce for stromboli should be the same sauce on pizza, it tasted a little like Arby's sauce"

- Seth
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Brother's Pizza & Restaurant offers more than just great food. Enjoy its laid-back environment. Here, the community gathers. There's a sense of camaraderie in every meal. Perfect for families, this spot knows how to cater to all ages.

Try their famous Stromboli or savory white pizza. Favorite dishes include meatball subs and steak hoagies. Their freshly made bread enhances the flavors, making every bite memorable. Perfect for lunch or dinner, the menu caters to various tastes.

Ordering is simple. Choose to dine in, take out, or have food delivered. Enjoy a quick lunch during weekdays or a family dinner on weekends. Peak times may bring a crowd, but tasty food is always worth the wait. Plan visits around less busy hours for a more relaxed experience.

Most Liked things

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant earns praise for its authentic flavors. The wood-fired pizzas receive consistent applause. Many enjoy the vibrant atmosphere that feels welcoming and casual.

Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, especially the homemade bread used in their subs. Favorites include the Italian sub and cheesesteak hoagie, which offer hearty portions at great prices. A reliable choice for families and takeout.

The staff remains friendly and chatty. They're ready to recommend dishes or answer questions. Regulars note the charming decor that adds to the inviting experience.

Most Disliked things

Some diners report service delays during peak hours, especially on busy Fridays and weekends. These wait times can frustrate when the restaurant is bustling. It's best to avoid busy hours if time is tight.

A few customers mention issues with orders, like cold food or undercooked items. However, the staff is typically eager to rectify any mistakes and ensure satisfaction. With patience, many still leave happy.

The limited payment options can disappoint some patrons. Brother's accepts cash and specific cards only. Diners should prepare accordingly to prevent any inconveniences during their visit.

FAQ

What types of cuisine does Brother's Pizza & Restaurant offer?

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant specializes in traditional pizza, subs, and salads. It’s perfect for a casual lunch or dinner, offering a taste of local favorites.

Is the restaurant family-friendly?

Yes, Brother's Pizza & Restaurant is family-friendly. Kids will enjoy a variety of menu options, and the relaxed atmosphere makes it easy for families to dine together.

Are there any vegetarian options available?

Yes, there are vegetarian options at Brother's Pizza & Restaurant. The menu features salads and some pizzas that can be customized with various toppings.

Does Brother's Pizza & Restaurant offer takeout services?

Yes, takeout services are available. Customers can conveniently order meals to go and enjoy delicious pizza or subs at home.

Is parking available near the restaurant?

Yes, there is free parking available on the street and a parking area for patrons. It ensures easy access for everyone visiting the restaurant.